How Trump could be impeached and removed but win re-election in 2020 – Business Insider
President Donald Trump is currently facing an impeachment inquiry led by three House committees, but he could still be re-elected in 2020 even if Congress removes him from office.
If a simple majority of the House votes to impeach Trump on one or more articles of impeachment, they go to the US Senate, which holds a trial.
Two-thirds of the Senate would have to vote to convict Trump to remove him from office.
Article I, Section 3 of the United States constitution says “judgment in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor.”
After convicting a federal officer, the Senate must separately vote by simple majority to prevent them from holding a federal office in the future, meaning Trump could still theoretically win re-election.
The scenario is highly implausible given the steadfast support of Trump’s base and a Republican-controlled Senate, but it shows how Trump has a route to redemption through the electoral process.
President Donald Trump is currently facing an impeachment inquiry led by three House of Representatives committees, but he could still be re-elected in 2020 even if Congress removes him from office.
Some conservative pundits have compared the impeachment inquiry to a coup, and have characterized Trump’s potential impeachment as the “ultimate penalty,” as conservative commentator Brit Hume did in a Saturday tweet.
But even if Trump were removed from his office by Congress, he could still redeem himself in the court of public opinion and through the electoral process.
The constitutional mechanism for the impeachment of a federal officer including presidents, vice presidents, and federal judges is laid out in Article II, Section 4 of the US constitution, which reads, “the President, Vice President and all civil officers of the United States, shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.”
The impeachment process begins in the House Judiciary Committee, which drafts and then approves articles of impeachment to be sent to the full House of Representatives by a vote.
The House voted to approve a formal resolution outlying the terms and parameters of its inquiry last week, but is still in the fact-finding stage of the process, hearing witness testimony and reviewing documents related to the inquiry.
If a simple majority of the entire House votes to impeach Trump on one or more of the articles, they go to the US Senate, which holds a trial on the charges overseen by the Chief Justice of the US Supreme Court. A two-thirds majority of the US Senate, or 67 senators if all 100 are present, must vote to convict in order to remove him from office.
Congress has never removed a president with the impeachment process before in America history. While two previous US presidents — Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton — were impeached by the House, both were acquitted in the Senate.
While the constitution lays out a mechanism to remove a president from office, it doesn’t prevent a president or other “civil officer” removed from their office by the impeachment process from running for office or being elected to federal office again.
Trump could theoretically run for office and be re-elected after a conviction in the Senate
Article I, Section 3 of the United States constitution explicitly says that in terms of political consequences, “judgment in cases of impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor, trust or profit under the United States.” (Officers who are impeached can still be indicted and prosecuted in a court of law.)
But according to a 2015 Congressional Research Service report, being convicted and removed from office doesn’t automatically lead to the “disqualification to hold and enjoy any office of honor.” After convicting a federal officer, the Senate must separately vote by simple majority to prevent them from holding a federal office in the future.
Rep. Alcee Hastings of Florida, for example, was impeached and removed from his position as a federal judge by Congress, but later elected to the US House of Representatives because the US Senate did not vote to disqualify him from holding future office after convicting him.
To be sure, this scenario is highly unlikely.
While the House is controlled by Democrats, it’s still not guaranteed that Trump will, in fact, be impeached. It’s even less plausible for him to be convicted by the GOP-controlled Senate, which is currently made up of 53 Republicans, 45 Democrats, and two independents that caucus with Democrats.
Trump currently benefits from a big “red wall” of 36 GOP senators from states where Trump’s approval rating swings more favorably, as Axios has reported. Fifteen of those senators are up for reelection in 2020, and an additional 10 senators represent states where Trump’s approval rating is underwater but are not up for reelection next year.
As Insider previously reported, Trump’s sky-high approval and favorability among the Republican Party and his takeover of the entire GOP apparatus means there is very little incentive for any Republican senators, including the vulnerable ones, to break with Trump knowing none of their colleagues have any reason to do so.
The latest 2019 American Values Survey. conducted August 22 to September 15 by the Public Religion Research Institute, further found that forty-five percent of Republicans without a college degree and fifty-five percent of GOP respondents who named Fox as their primary news source — two demographics Trump relies on— say there was absolutely nothing Trump could do to lose their support.
If Trump’s base significantly abandoned him to the point where 20 GOP senators felt comfortable voting to remove him, it’s also unlikely that the American electorate would then vote to re-elect him.
Trump’s re-election would also be contingent on Vice President Mike Pence — who would become president if Trump were removed from office — stepping aside and not running for the Republican presidential nomination. Still, Trump has a theoretical route to be sworn in as president again in 2021 even if the Senate does remove him from office.